Isabel Garcia of Coalicion de Derechos Humanos responds
Jul 26, 2008 For your information, Immigration Debate, Talk Radio
Good afternoon, and thank you for allowing me to respond in writing, as I am presently out of town.
As you know, Derechos Humanos, along with 6-7 community groups, called for a protest of Joe Arpaio’s appearance at his book signing at the Barnes and Noble. Because of Maricopa Sheriff’s Arpaio’s outrageous police actions in the communities of Phoenix, as well as his political views surrounding the immigration issues in general, many of us in Tucson have made a promise that we will not allow him to come into our town without him hearing from those of us who stand in support of the thousands of workers and their families who have borne the brunt of his narrow-minded, ignorant policies. That he would come to Tucson to promote a book filled with lies, fear, and ignorant perspectives about immigrants, was especially appalling to us.
We stand for the principles of peace and justice. We live in a very precarious moment in history, where, again, human beings are being demonized and scapegoated, exploiting on the ugly and fearful in all of us. Derechos Humanos protested Arpaio, handing out flyers, briefly explaining why,and what he has done in Phoenix. You can have one of our leaflets if you would like, but among other things we denounce his antics that have created great racial divisions in Phoenix, at a more than $41,000,000 cost to the taxpayers, and a few other actions he has engaged in. The leaflet states that we “continue to work for a community that is diverse, respectful, and appreciative of each other’s differences.” Others brought signs and megaphones, with someone bringing a large piñata with Arpaio’s face glued on the head. I am sure you are aware that these types of symbolic images are not only common, but generally are used in context of referring to the policies of individuals in power.
I am now the target of a corporate-media-sponsored campaign to get me fired from my job as the Pima County Legal Defender. The first thing that you should know is that this is not a community-based campaign by those that disagree with me, but a campaign that was instigated by Jon Justice (not his true name) who has a program in the new hate-radio in town, 104.1 FM. On Friday morning, he was on his program urging everyone to call Chuck Huckelberry to fire me because I dared exercise my 1st Amendment right to express my views. They cover it by saying that the breaking of a piñata is a violent act! ??? That is simply absurd. The piñata was a symbol of Arpaio’s racist, violent and brutal policies. The youth did not hit Arpaio, they hit the piñata to break the policies that keep us fearful of each other, and that have caused so much pain to so many hardworking men, women and their children. He is the violent one. I have spoken directly to some of his victims/survivors of his power, and have cried just listening to their accounts. US citizen and undocumented children alike have suffered the separation from their mothers, fathers, and siblings. People have lost their homes, families separated, their whole lives being violently disrupted by this horrible person, Arpaio. As a public official he should be aware of the facts: immigrants have contributed and continue to contribute to our society, they are human beings entitled to respect for their human rights, including the right to work and survive, and the right to be free from his unconstitutional interpretation of the laws.
I am proud to have been part of the community’s response to his arrival in Tucson. We stand committed to stop hatred and xenophobia, and to work for a society that respects human rights for everyone regardless of their age, color, race, ethnic background, gender, gender-preference, religion. As an attorney I find it is not only my right, but my responsibility to stand up when the power of the state is used to crush people. I will continue to do so.
-Isabel Garcia
This lady deserves our continued support.
This post was read 423 times until now
These might be of interest
Tags: 104.1, Human Rights, Isabel Garcia, Jon Justice






























September 25th, 2008 at 1:55
This was a symbolic lynching of Arpaio, and that doesn’t bother you? Suppose someone shows up somewhere and beats up a figure of Isabel Garcia? Was the pinata filled with candies for the kiddies — or was it a means of threatening and intimidating a man who is enforcing U.S. laws?
View this Comment in:
September 25th, 2008 at 2:18
No, it does not bother me. The right to protest is protected under the First Amendment. Had it been the reverse and the pinata was a likeness of Garcia, I would not have been concerned.
Yhe problem I have is the rancor and hate displayed by Justice and others against this woman who did nothing more than pick up the head of the pinata and hold it aloft as all the videos show.
She did not participate in the demonstration nor organize it.
We both know had her name been Mary Jane Smith or Ida May Jones, the response would have never reached this level.
Joe Arpaio is a fucktard pure and simple! Immigration enforcement to begin with is a Federal matter. Mariposa County has enough crime and criminals for Sheriff Joe to get his face time in the media with, without making questionable traffic stops in search of illegals.
Furthermore, Sheriff Jow seems to forget that under our system of Justice, people are supposed to be innocent until proven guilty in a Court of Law.
That means humane treatment for people in his facilities instead of treating them as less than humans and forcing them to endure daily humiliations. ie: pink underwear and green bologna for lunch.
This just illustrates the need to turn a deaf ear to all the bullshit of the neo con right wing who will accept nothing less than imprisoning all 12 million “illegal Mexicans” in this country, and work towards a logical and common sense solution to the broken immigration system.
And notice I mentioned only Mexican illegals? Mexican’s are all that count in the anti-immigration debate. In the minds of this segment, no other illegals exist.
View this Comment in: